Sharon4Council 3

SHARONS SUMMIT v.SICKO ST.PAUL SKIMMING SECURITYS TIF-STAR MONEY

SHARONS SUMMIT v.SICKO ST.PAUL SKIMMING SECURITYS TIF-STAR MONEY
Realestate Flipping-Skimming by sicko st.paul Oficials

Crimes Against Humanity

Opinions

Video's,Sicko,UTube,SharonAnderson,St.Paul Elections,Oprah,Mike Moore,ButtersTPAUL,

Loading...

Monday, December 28, 2009

Sharon v. CitySt.Paul 62cv09-1163_A09-2031(Toussaint)

City's hard lesson: Even a $1 price tag won't sell these houses

Three houses and a duplex stand vacant on St. Paul's East Side. The city is offering several of the houses for one dollar, so far they continue to stand empty. Saturday, December 26, 2009. (Pioneer Press: John Autey)
Homes offered for rock-bottom prices in August sit empty

When you can't sell a home that you've priced at $1, what's your next step?

Cut the price to 50 cents?

Try paying someone to take the house for a buck?

St. Paul officials have learned some disappointing — but not surprising — lessons four months into a project to sell a cluster of city-owned homes at prices ranging from $50,000 all the way down to a buck.

In August, the city's Housing and Redevelopment Agency sponsored a series of open houses for the HRA-owned properties clustered along the west end of Fourth Street in the Dayton's Bluff neighborhood. City officials said they would sell only to buyers who showed they could finance extensive repairs that satisfy both city rules and historic preservation guidelines.

But despite heavy turnout at the open houses, the city has received only three purchase proposals thus far, said Sheryl Pemberton-Hoiby of the city's Department of Planning and Economic Development. Only one of the proposals, she added, likely will result in a sale.

Potential buyers have been daunted by the scope of rehab work needed on the houses, said Ellen Biales, aide to City Council President Kathy Lantry. Another concern: Many of the properties lack off-street parking.

"People want garages," said Pemberton-Hoiby.

As the number of foreclosures has skyrocketed in recent years in the Twin Cities and across the country, cities like St. Paul have taken on the role of buying houses to address a sharp increase in

vacant properties. Those vacancies can contribute to a downward spiral in values for other homeowners in the neighborhood.

The result is that St. Paul now finds itself with not just the 11 homes in Dayton's Bluff, but another 59 properties spread across the city. About 30 of the homes likely will be demolished, but city officials hope to sell the others and promote neighborhood redevelopment efforts.

The Dayton's Bluff program — known as the Fourth Street Preservation Project — was meant to test strategies for how the city might best sell its homes. The key lesson learned thus far: More investment in rehabilitating the homes on the front-end is needed to entice buyers.

As one example, St. Paul is doing some initial surveying work to show potential buyers options for creating off-street parking at some of the Dayton's Bluff homes. The city also is considering improvements to exteriors and mechanical systems in the houses.

"People want to see the city's involvement — that they're not the only ones taking on the risk," Pemberton-Hoiby said.

With the additional investment, those $1 prices likely will be a thing of the past as the city looks to recoup the money.

In one respect, the city's effort has coincided with some helpful trends in the local housing market, where a lot of the activity among buyers has been focused on low-price homes.

Between December 2008 and last month, more than 12,000 homes priced at $120,000 or less have sold in the 13-county metro area, according to the Minneapolis Area Association of Realtors. That's a nearly 95 percent increase over the number of sales in that price bracket during the previous 12-month period.

Plus, there's been added incentive in recent months to purchase in Dayton's Bluff and nearby neighborhoods. In April, the Pohlad Family Foundation announced a $1 million grant to provide buyers in the 55106 ZIP code — an area that includes Dayton's Bluff — with $8,000.

But all of the foundation funds have now been committed, said Zong Vang of Dayton's Bluff Neighborhood Housing Services of St. Paul, the nonprofit group that is managing the grant money.

And the demand for low-price homes has been stoked by a huge supply of the properties, meaning buyers looking for discounted homes have had a lot of choices. The city's properties have been going up against some tough competition in the under-$100,000 price bracket, said Brad Griffith, an agent with Edina Realty who has worked with buyers and sellers on St. Paul's East Side.

Some buyers who've been looking for deals in homes priced at $25,000 to $40,000, Griffith said, wind end up opting for higher priced homes — say about $80,000 — when they see how the higher price tag translates into significantly less rehab work.

Griffith said he's not familiar with details of the Fourth Street Preservation Project, but suggested that city officials might want to consider working with local real estate brokers to market the homes. That way, the homes could be listed on the Regional MLS of Minnesota, a propriety database used by Realtors.

"The MLS is helpful from the exposure standpoint," Griffith said.

Better marketing would help the Fourth Street project, agreed Chuck Repke, executive director of the Northeast Neighborhoods Development Corp. But there have been other challenges.

Many recent buyers of homes under $120,000 are investors looking to rent the properties or sell them following rehabilitation. The city wants to sell to buyers who will live in the properties.

Repke said he agreed with the city's focus on owners who will be residents, but noted that those buyers constitute a much smaller group. Another challenge: Potential buyers are having trouble finding loans to finance the extensive rehab projects that are required to live in the Dayton's Bluff homes.

"I think you can stimulate people to buy St. Paul," Repke said. "Before all of the markets collapsed everywhere, we were finding people making that decision to come back to the urban core. ... If the credit market changes on some of this stuff, I think there will be buyers."

Pemberton-Hoiby, the city official who is project manager on the Fourth Street effort, said the city has not marketed the homes through the MLS because the sales come with so many strings attached in terms of rehabilitation requirements that the houses aren't standard listings. Even so, she said, the city is looking at ways it could compensate real estate agents for bringing buyers.

While city officials would have liked to have sold some of the 11 homes by now, Pemberton-Hoiby said the properties in Dayton's Bluff and those elsewhere in the city continue to offer chances at improving neighborhoods.

"Most of the properties we're picking up haven't been rehabbed in a long time," she said, "if at all."

Christopher Snowbeck can be reached at 651-228-5479.

Saturday, December 5, 2009

JURIST - Paper Chase: DOJ civil rights enforcement dropped under Bush administration: report

JURIST - Paper Chase: DOJ civil rights enforcement dropped under Bush administration: reportDOJ civil rights enforcement dropped under Bush administration: report
Jaclyn Belczyk at 3:08 PM ET

Photo source or description
[JURIST] Enforcement of various civil rights laws decreased during the Bush administration, according to a
report [text, PDF; summary] released Thursday by the US Government Accountability Office (GAO) [official website]. The GAO studied the activities of the Civil Rights Division of the US Department of Justice (DOJ) [official websites] between 2001 and 2007. According to the report, DOJ lawsuits to enforce laws prohibiting race or sex discrimination in employment fell [NYT report] from about 11 per year under the Clinton administration to about 6 per year under the Bush administration. There was also a drop in the number of cases brought under the Voting Rights Act from more than four cases a year under Clinton to fewer than two cases a year under Bush. The US House of Representatives held a hearing [materials; recorded video] Thursday on oversight of the Civil Rights Division, at which GAO Director of Homeland Security and Justice Issues Eileen Regen Larence recommended [testimony, PDF]:

that to strengthen the Division's ability to manage and report on the four sections' enforcement efforts, the Acting Assistant Attorney General of the Division, among other things, (1) require sections to record data on protected class and subject in the Division's case management system in order to facilitate reporting of this information to Congress, and (2) as the Division considers options to address its case management system needs, determine how sections should be required to record data on the reasons for closing matters in the system in order to be able to systematically assess and take actions to address issues identified.

Assistant Attorney General Thomas Perez [official profile] said [testimony, PDF] that the DOJ is "working to comply fully with the GAO's recommendations."

In September, US
Attorney General Eric Holder [official profile] said that the DOJ planned to expand its Civil Rights Division [JURIST report] and more actively enforce anti-discrimination laws. The increased focus on civil rights marks a change in focus from the previous administration, which, according to the New York Times [NYT report; JURIST report], shifted resources from preventing racial discrimination to protecting religious rights. Among the new measures described by Holder were President Barack Obama's plan to add more than 50 lawyers to the Civil Rights Division and increased enforcement of anti-discrimination laws in areas in which minorities are often adversely affected, including housing and employment. At his swearing-in ceremony, Holder pledged [JURIST report] to restore the traditions of fairness and neutrality to the department.



Link

Friday, December 4, 2009

SharonsFOIA_S&Cpdf_Chapter13OpenMeeting

Wed.9Dec09 City's Agenda(No Public Hearing)
Fri.4Dec09
OPEN FOIA_DEMAND BY CITIZEN SHARON4ANDERSON
In Compliance with Obama's Demands. Open Meeting Laws etc.
Affidavit of Sharon4Anderson, current Candidate State AG
Please take legal notice Affiant is in MN Appellate Court A09-2031
ISSUES: Pursuant to Open Meeting Laws Chapter 13D
That any/all S&C mandate Public Hearings? 9Dec.09 that 2 S&C Enviro and Police Federation are suing the City.
FOIA, Title 5 Freedom Of Information Act,
That any all S&C mandate pdf format for public policy and preview.

Sharon Anderson Anoka Co. Attorney Robert Johnson traveled to Michigan, Constitutional Right to Lawyer, Hey We have the Right to Attorney Pro Se,InFact and Private AG

http://www.facebook.com/l.php?u=
www.constitutionproject.org
Home - About Us - Calendar - Committees - Library - Newsletter - Newsroom © Copyright 2009 The Constitution Project, Some Rights Reserved
7 hours ago · · · Share
January 21st, 2009

On Day One, Obama Demands Open Government

Deeplink by Marcia Hofmann

It's only his first day in office, but President Obama has already signaled a serious commitment to transparency and accountability in government. The President ordered federal agencies in a memorandum released today to approach the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) "with a clear presumption: in the face of doubt, openness prevails."

http://stpaul.granicus.com/AgendaViewer.php?view_id=37&event_id=1
Ph: (651) 266-8688
Fx: (651) 266-8574
Contact

Shari Moore
City Clerk
AGENDA OF THE SAINT PAUL CITY COUNCIL
Wednesday, December 9, 2009 - 3:30 p.m.
CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS, 3RD FLOOR
City Hall and Court House
15 West Kellogg Boulevard



CONSENT AGENDA (Items 1 - 19)

COMMUNICATIONS AND ADMINISTRATIVE ORDERS

1. Claims of American Family Insurance Group (for Kathleen Montour), Elisea Cervantes Anzures, Flerida D. Cummings, Jennifer T. Lint, Ian M Brunzell-Looney, Elizabeth A Moldrem, Vicki and Craig Nilles, David M Selden (JD Properties), and Gidget S. Todd.

2. Summons and complaint in the matter of Enviro Tech Remediation Services, Inc. vs. the City of Saint Paul, et al.

3. Summons and Complaint in the matter of the St. Paul Police Federation, et al. vs. the City of Saint Paul, et al.

4. Letter from the Department of Planning and Economic Development announcing a public hearing before the City Council on December 16, 2009 to consider the appeal of Semple Enterprises to a decision of the Zoning Commission denying an application to establish legal non-conforming use at 91 Ridder Circle. [ZF 09-327-588]

5. Letter from the Department of Financial Services/Real Estate announcing a public hearing before the City Council on December 16, 2009 to consider approval and implementation of the 2010 rate for the Service Availability Charge (SAC) imposed by the Metropolitan Council - Environmental Services as of January 1, 2010.

6. Letter from the Department of Safety and Inspections announcing a public hearing before the City Council on January 6, 2010 to consider the appeal of a decision by the Board of Zoning Appeals granting a variance of the spacing requirements for an electronic message board sign at 1891 Suburban Avenue. [ZF 09-330789]

FOR ACTION

7. Resolution - 09-1315 - Approving the Memorandum of Agreement between the City of Saint Paul and Saint Paul Fire Fighters Local 21 to amend the 2008-2010 Collective Bargaining Agreement-Article 18 Volunteerism and/or Outside Employment. [Laid over from December 2 for adoption] (GS 3088996-Ward 7)

8. Resolution - 09-1335 - Approving the Memorandum of Agreement between the City of Saint Paul and the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, Local 110, 2009 Wage and Fringe Adjustment. [To be laid over one week for adoption] (GS 3088516-Ward 7)

9. Resolution - 09-1336 - Approving the appointment of Anne Hunt, by Mayor Coleman, to the Downtown Airport Advisory Council. (GS 3087858-Ward 7)

10. Resolution - 09-1337 - Approving the reappointments of John Manning, Steve Trimble, and David Riehle, and the appointments of Matt Mazanec, Jennifer Haskamp, Robert Ferguson, and Richard Lafflin, by Mayor Coleman, to the Heritage Preservation Commission. (GS 3087860-Ward 7)

11. Resolution - 09-1338 - Approving the reappointments of Ann Bibeau, Shirley Hunt, Renee Skoglund, Sally Staggert, and Arlend "Buzz" Wilson, by Mayor Coleman, to the Advisory Committee on Aging. (GS 3087861-Ward 7)

12. Resolution - 09-1339 - Authorizing the Mayor’s Office to submit the Competitive Energy Efficiency and Conservation Block Grant Application to the U.S. Department of Energy with the City of Minneapolis for developing a comprehensive energy retrofit program in targeted neighborhoods in the two cities. (GS 3090256-Ward 4)

13. Resolution - 09-1340 - Approving final Midway Shopping Center proposal and agreement relating to administrative extension of site plan approval. (GS 3090257-Ward 1)

14. Resolution - 09-1341 - Authorizing the Fire Department to enter into an agreement with Dakota County Technical College to provide an Emergency Response Driving course to firefighters. (GS 3089236-Ward 7)

15. Resolution - 09-1342 - Authorizing the Department of Parks and Recreation to accept intern funding from the Capitol Region Watershed District. (GS 3086716-Ward 7)

16. Resolution - 09-1343 - Amending Council File 09-499 by deleting the assessment for property cleanup from December 31, 2008 to January 14, 2009 for property at 841 Cook Avenue East. (GS 3089716-Ward 6)

17. Resolution - 09-1344 - Amending Council File 09-946, memorialization of an appeal to a Certificate of Occupancy Deficiency List for property at 1591 Blair Avenue. (GS 3089476-Ward 4)

18. Resolution - 09-1345 - Approving the decisions of the Legislative Hearing Officer for Appeals to Letters of Certificate of Occupancy Deficiency Lists and Denial of Building Permits to Replace Egress Windows for properties at: 1345 Colby Avenue, 701 Cottage Avenue West, 2043 Itasca Avenue, 1589 Chamber Street, 669 Dayton Avenue, and 556 Ashland Avenue. (GS 3090196)

19. Resolution - 09-1346 - Approving the decisions of the Legislative Hearing Office on Appeals of Letters of Deficiency and Vacant Building Registration Notice and Fees for properties at: 962 Como Avenue, 1716 Grand Avenue, 918 Goodrich Avenue, 1552 Como Avenue, 425 Roy Street North, 595 Hamline Avenue North, 1368 Pleasant Avenue, 1124 Norton Street, 585 Charles Avenue, 297 Thomas Avenue, 395 Thomas Avenue, 2298 Rockwood Avenue, and 326 Harrison Avenue. (GS 3089596)

FOR DISCUSSION

20. Resolution - 09-1347 - Recognizing the November 17, 2009 recipients of the Commuter Choice awards. (GS 3089676-Ward 4)

21. Resolution - 08-414 - Ordering the owner to remove the building(s) at 22 Douglas Street within fifteen (15) days from adoption of resolution. [Public hearing held May 7, 2008; laid over from August 12, 2009] (GS 3049924-Ward 2)

22. Consideration of the application of Abdalla Tobasi to rezone property at 857 Selby Avenue (northeast corner at Victoria Street) from B2 Community Business to TN2 Traditional Neighborhood. [ZF 09-273-676] [Laid over from November 18](Ward 1)

ORDINANCES

23. Final Adoption - 09-1015 - An ordinance amending Chapter 64 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code regarding signs with dynamic display. [Substitute introduced December 2] (GS 3077776-Ward 7)

24. Final Adoption - 09-1287 - An ordinance amending Chapter 140 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code outlining requirements for various skyway signs. (GS 3086956-Ward 2)

25. Final Adoption - 09-1289 - An ordinance amending Chapter 331A of the Saint Paul Legislative Code to require allergy awareness posters in restaurants. (GS 3085976-Ward 1)

26. Final Adoption - 09-1290 - An ordinance amending Chapter 310.19 of the Saint Paul Legislative Code to grant discounts to restaurant license fees for allergen training. [Substitute introduced December 2] (GS 3086078-Ward 1)

27. First Reading - 09-1348 - An ordinance creating Chapter 175A of the Saint Paul Legislative Code to declare emerald ash borer a nuisance and create a method for dealing with the threat to ash trees on public and private property. (GS 3088876-Ward 7)

19
Therefore: Please send the S&C as Attachments and or pdf the url and have a Public Hearing.

LEGAL NOTICE: /s/Sharon4Anderson@aol.com ECF_P165913Pacersa1299 telfx: 651-776-5835:
Attorney ProSe_InFact,Private Attorney General QuiTam Whistleblower, Sharon4 Anderson - Google Profile Candidate AG2010 http://www.sharonagmn2010.blogspot.com/Blogger: User Profile: Sharon Anderson SharonsYahoo! iGoogle

Homestead Act of 1862 Twitter / Sharon4Anderson Shar1058's Buzz Activity Page - My Buzz Activity - Yahoo! Buzz neopopulism.org - Pro Se Dec Action Litigation Pack Sharon4Anderson Scribd Document's are based on SEC filings, Blogger: Dashboard Home

FAIR USE NOTICEThis site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of whistleblower protection issues, MY FindLaw SharonsWritProA06_1150_30Jun06_26
The CAN-SPAM Act: Requirements for Commercial Emailers
kare11.com_SA
Sharons-Psychic-Whispers: Sharons Gypsy Curse-Court-Cop Corruption 3Apr0http://www.givemeliberty.org/RTPlawsuit/courtfilings/Docket.htm Sharon4Council: DLJ Management v. City St. Paul A06-2118,Money LaunderinNo direct un-apportioned tax confirmed by the US Supreme Court rulings in CHAS. C. STEWARD MACH. CO. v. DAVIS, 301 U.S. 548, 581-582(1937)
g andFCC Complaints - http://sharons-copywrite.blogspot.com/knowledge gained as financial journalists , http://taxthemax.blogspot.com/ securities they recommend to readers, affiliated entities, employees, and agents an initial trade Public domain recommendation published on the Internet, after a direct mail publication is sent, before acting Google Search Times v. Sullvian Libel with malice - on that recommendations, and may contain errors. Investment decisions should not be based solely on these or other Public Office documents expressly forbids its writers from having financial interests in Google Search BlogItBabe2007 Candidate profile Sharon4Anderson's Legal BlogBriefs Sharon4And
ect:CityofSt.Paul,MN - Agnd9Dec09_SharonsFOIA_S&C_pdf.
Date:12/4/2009 2:48:18 P.M. Central Standard Time
From:Sharon4Anderson

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

Sharon Anderson,Bill Dahn v.Aaron Foster,CitySt.Paul

THANK YOU TO ALL4 HAPPY,HEALTHY,HEALING HOLIDAYS
24NOV09 Sharons 62cv09-1163 Appeal A09-2031
AFFIDAVITS OF SHARON L. ANDERSON AKA CHERGOSKY-PETERSON-SCARRELLA AND WILLIAM PAUL DAHN, Protected Class
DECEDANTS: JIM CASCI,JIM ANDERSON,TENANTS IN COMMON
BILL AND BERNICE PETERSON,HEIRS,ASSIGNS,ET AL.BARBACLU of MN Lantry St. Paul Inspection WINN ET AL.
To Shari Moore City Clerk Email et as interests appear
310 City Hall 15 Kellogg Blvd., West
Saint Paul, MN 55102
In the Matter of Aaron Foster Sr. v. City St.Paul et al
rcvd by City 13Nov09 without Filing Fee or Court ID
2. Summons and Complaint in the matter of Aaron W. Foster Sr. vs. the City of Saint Paul.
ISSUES:
A. AFFIANTS,DECEDANTS,CITIZENERY OF ST.PAUL, reserve the Right and Privilege to Intervene, Amicus Curie in what ever court or Administrative Hearing Aaron Foster Appear's.
B. THEREFORE: The legislative Branch City Council, must suspend item no. (2) Grant Public Hearing, Witness's, Testimony and DSI Employees such as Aaron Foster's X Wife Lisa Martin, and reopen over 3 thousand propertys re: 2008 Tax Delinquent Ramsey Dist. Crt. 62cv09-1163, that had towed Cars,Furniture, at the St.Paul Police Impound Lot.
Case law Brief:
Affiant Sharon, by information and belief and as told to Sharon the Following
Sharon verily believes Jim Casci was " Murdered" to keep from testify before Judge Edward Cleary in the Foster and Sholoman Case's,

I donated thousands for dollars to the to St Paul Harley Davidson and Tom Gianetti along with Bill Finney for the annual diabetes foundation. The funds were given to Aaron Foster to give to this cause but 90% were never derived, this I can prove. I have requested records from Tom Gianetti, St Paul Harley Davidson, Diabetes Foundation, and the U of M, but have received nothing. All contribution made thru Mr. Aaron Foster. Oh, and I am barred from St Paul Harley Davidson. "Guilty"

The St Paul Police Department tried to intimidate me with 32 moving violations, and I beat them all. It all started when I said I was going to

Note to Joe: update your MN Eminent Domain for Public Policy
Randy Furst Thanks for Strike Force Info: Re: Bud Shaver and http://www.alicekrengel.blogspot.com/ MNSupPrecedant. Kory Land http://www.levander.com/
25 yrs later still fighting the Corrupt System When you have time read the NOTE TO JUDGE JOHN VANDENORTH:
Re: Apparantly the undersign humbly request that you get a Mental and Physical Exam as Your Memory Loss is either Covert or Complicit.
FURTHER: Full disclosure by ALL Judges in their lack of Computer knowledge is pervase/fatal and puts the MN Judiciary at risk for Ignorance.
IGNORANCE OF THE LAW IS NO EXCUSE THEREFORE IGNORANCE
OF HIGH TECH COMPUTER SCIENCE, FORENSIC FILES TO PLEAD
BY PHONE,E-COMMNERCE,SKYPE(SP) IS ALSO NO EXCUSE TO DENY
DUE PROCESS, BLOW THE WHISTLE ON CITY,COUNTY CORRUPTION.
www.slideshare.com/sharon4anderson Transcript of Judge John Vandenorth, MEMORY LOSS MANDATES FULL DISCLOSURE OF THESE JUDGES WHO ARE INCOMPETANT IN THE HIGH TECH OF THE WWW www.taxthemax.blogspot.com pg. 17 "Can't remember" Judge John Vandenorth ie: Bill Dahn
Hey the recent law suit of Aaron Foster v. City St.Paul apparent former Manager of St.Paul Police Impound Lot re: Sharons91 Chrysler with disabled plates, Trailer etc. must reopen not only the 3 thousand alleged Property Tax 2008 Delinquency's based on Alleged Summary "Abatements" Nuisance laws without Criminal Charges must be incompassed into A09-2031

From: cwalsh@ij.org
To: sharon4anderson@aol.com
Sent: 11/24/2009 10:25:59 A.M. Central Standard Time
Subj: New York High Court Upholds Eminent Domain for Private Gain
INSTITUTE FOR JUSTICE
901 N. GLEBE ROAD SUITE 900 ARLINGTON, VA 22203 (703) 682-9320 FAX (703) 682-9321
HOME PAGE: WWW.IJ.ORG

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
November 24, 2009

New York High Court Upholds
Eminent Domain for Private Gain


Arlington, Va.—The New York Court of Appeals, the state’s highest court, today announced that it would uphold the decision of the Empire State Development Corporation (ESDC) to condemn privately owned homes and small businesses to make way for wealthy developer Bruce Ratner’s so-called “Atlantic Yards” development of 16 mammoth skyscrapers centered around a basketball arena.

“Today’s decision puts homes and businesses throughout New York at risk of condemnation,” said Dana Berliner, a senior attorney at the Institute for Justice (IJ), which filed a friend-of-the-court brief in the case. “Courts have a duty to look carefully at the government’s claim that it has the right to take someone’s home or business, and the Court of Appeals has simply refused to do that.”

While upholding the taking, the New York court did not go so far as to embrace the United States Supreme Court’s much-maligned reasoning in the 2005 Kelo v. City of New London case, which held that the U.S. Constitution allows governments to condemn property for economic development alone. Instead, the Court found the takings were for a “public use” because of the ESDC’s determination that the area to be condemned was “blighted”—a determination that was based on a study paid for by the would-be developer and not even initiated until years after the Atlantic Yards project was announced.

In a dissent, Judge Robert Smith excoriated the majority for abandoning its duty to critically examine the ESDC’s assertions. “To let the agency itself determine when the public use requirement is satisfied is to make the agency a judge in its own cause,” Judge Smith wrote. “I think that it is we who should perform the role of judges, and that we should do so by deciding that the proposed taking in this case is not for public use.”

“The developer’s study did not find anything a normal person would call ‘blight,’” explained Berliner. “Instead, it found that the neighborhood was ‘underutilized’—in other words, that the developer could think of bigger things that could be built where these homes and businesses are. If that is all that is necessary for condemnation, then literally every piece of property in New York is at risk.”

The majority’s opinion frankly acknowledges that the court may be opening the door to “political appointees to public corporations relying on studies paid for by developers . . . [as] a predicate for the invasion of property rights and the razing of homes and businesses.” But, it says, preventing such abuses is not the job of the courts, advising New Yorkers to look to their legislature to fix any problems.

“New York is one of only seven states that has failed utterly to pass any kind of eminent-domain reform in the wake of the Kelo decision, and today’s opinion will only make things worse,” said IJ Staff Attorney Robert McNamara. “The state courts are looking to the legislature to fix the problem, while the legislature is apparently looking to the courts. And that means more and more New Yorkers will be looking at condemnation notices.”

“Property rights are as sacred to citizens of New York as they are to Americans nationwide, and New Yorkers have rightly looked to their courts to protect those rights,” concluded IJ President and General Counsel Chip Mellor. “Today’s opinion should be a clarion call to the state legislature that they cannot avoid this issue any longer. Now is the time to give state residents the reform and protections they desperately need.”

###
Christina Walsh
Director of Activism and Coalitions
Institute for Justice
901 N. Glebe Road, Suite 900
Arlington, VA 22203
(703) 682-9320
(703) 682-9321 - fax
www.ij.org
www.castlecoalition.org



This message was sent from Christina Walsh to sharon4anderson@aol.com. It was sent from: Institute for Justice, Institute for Justice 901 N. Glebe Road, Suite 900, Arlington, VA 22203. You can modify/update your subscription via the link below.

Email Marketing by
http://www.icontact.com/a.pl/144186


Manage your subscription http://app.icontact.com/icp/sub/forward?m=

LEGAL NOTICE: /s/Sharon4Anderson@aol.com ECF_P165913Pacersa1299
telfx: 651-776-5835:
Attorney ProSe_InFact,Private Attorney General QuiTam Whistleblower,
Sharon4 Anderson - Google Profile Candidate AG2010 http://www.sharonagmn2010.blogspot.com/Blogger: User Profile: Sharon Anderson SharonsYahoo! iGoogle

Homestead Act of 1862 Twitter / Sharon4Anderson Shar1058's Buzz Activity Page - My Buzz Activity - Yahoo! Buzz neopopulism.org - Pro Se Dec Action Litigation Pack Sharon4Anderson Scribd Document's are based on SEC filings, Blogger: Dashboard Home

FAIR USE NOTICEThis site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of whistleblower protection issues, MY FindLaw SharonsWritProA06_1150_30Jun06_26
The CAN-SPAM Act: Requirements for Commercial Emailers
kare11.com_SA
Sharons-Psychic-Whispers: Sharons Gypsy Curse-Court-Cop Corruption 3Apr0http://www.givemeliberty.org/RTPlawsuit/courtfilings/Docket.htm Sharon4Council: DLJ Management v. City St. Paul A06-2118,Money LaunderinNo direct un-apportioned tax confirmed by the US Supreme Court rulings in CHAS. C. STEWARD MACH. CO. v. DAVIS, 301 U.S. 548, 581-582(1937)
g andFCC Complaints - http://sharons-copywrite.blogspot.com/knowledge gained as financial journalists , http://taxthemax.blogspot.com/ securities they recommend to readers, affiliated entities, employees, and agents an initial trade Public domain recommendation published on the Internet, after a direct mail publication is sent, before acting Google Search Times v. Sullvian Libel with malice - on that recommendations, and may contain errors. Investment decisions should not be based solely on these or other Public Office documents expressly forbids its writers from having financial interests in Google Search BlogItBabe2007 Candidate profile Sharon4Anderson's Legal BlogBriefs Sharon4And

YouTube - Sharon4Anderson's Channel

Balance the Budgets aka St.Paul,MN

Supreme Court Watch | PBS

Search This Blog

Sharon4Mayor2010

Common Law

Property Tax's Paid,Double Taxaction

Property Tax's Paid,Double Taxaction